Chaos or Cleanliness – A Creative’s Conundrum

Sage Bray's studio showing the clean and messy versions side by side.
Sage Bray's studio showing the comparison to the clean vs messy states.

The concept of neatness has been venerated in the vast majority of societies for thousands of years. Buddhism’s and Christianity’s call to shed one’s earthly possessions to gain spirituality was a sacred principle thousands of years before the minimalist art movement of the mid-20th century sparked a desire for a simpler way of life. And this was decades before Marie Kondo came in with her “spark joy” delineation for paring down one’s belongings. It is a bit ironic then, that a movement with such a fervent following, kicked off, in recent history, by architects, painters and sculptors, never seems to have taken hold within the majority of artist’s studios.

Sadly, a lack of neatness and simplicity is often a source of shame, with artists tidying up their spaces and stashing their stockpile of art supplies normally scattered across the tables before snapping pics or shooting videos to post or sell. But let’s get real. Art is messy, wonderfully so. Messy is, however, quite relative, mostly to the individual. A tendency for a messy or neat space is personal and ranges from a managed inclination to an uncontrollable propensity for one extreme or the other. Regardless, the one thing that doesn’t belong in the assessment of one’s studio organization is judgment. It is not good or bad or right or wrong to have a neat or messy studio.

What does belong in a discussion of messy versus neat spaces is how your preference or propensity serves in your creative space. Let me explain. 

Let’s say Alex is a messy polymer artist. Like really messy. Paint and powders are splashed and dashed about like a Holi color festival went through, tools are buried alive and hoping for search parties, and raw clay bits have tumbled to the floor in a rainbow pool of forgotten experiments. If this makes Alex happy, then great. But if Alex wants to create intentional art that isn’t marred by errant powders and will be done before his next big show, he needs to have a relatively clean area and quick access to the right tools. So, in that case the mess wouldn’t serve him very well and raining the chaos in should be considered.

On the other hand, there’s Mina. With a place for everything and everything in its place, she spends the first hour of her studio time, cleaning, polishing, and labeling drawers to keep everything perfectly organized, and she wraps up a every session with a similarly lengthy period of time cleaning up after herself. To create and maintain this palace of magnificent neatness, she scours the Pinterest boards for organizational ideas and makes regular trips to the Container store. Mina spends a lot of time staying neat and organized but has yet to complete a line of work that she would be proud to list in her yet to be launched online shop. Whether it’s obsession or procrastination, her level of neatness is taking time away from the creative endeavors that would serve her end objectives. 

Most artists are somewhere in between these two extremes and only they can say whether their space is too messy or too neat for what they are trying to do. The only issue is that most creatives have a hard time being objective about how well their space serves them. So how would you know if you are being too messy or too neat for what you need? 

Well, there have been many independent studies on the neatness versus messy quandary, revealing quite a bit about the role of our spaces in terms of creativity and productivity.
Kathleen Vohs, a researcher at the University of Minnesota conducted a number of studies on the question of how neat and messy spaces affect us. In the most relative experiment for creative’s, 48 subjects were asked to come up with alternate ways to use a ping pong ball. Subjects in a messy room came up with significantly more creative ideas than their counterparts in a tidy, organized room. An unrelated research group at Northwestern University, had similar results, finding that subjects in a messy room drew more creative pictures and were quicker to solve challenging brainteaser puzzles than subjects in a tidy room. These experiments seem to support the concept that neatness encourages conventional ideas while a bit of chaos stimulates creativity and innovation. 

Artists themselves have also been a great source of evidence to support the need for some disorder. From Francis Bacon to Mark Twain to Pollack and Einstein, there have been numerous observations and biographical anecdotes that seem to show clutter and chaos are not just supportive creative environments but may actually be a source for inspiration. The experience of many polymer artists supports this as well, with many a story of cast off polymer trimmings suddenly calling to their masters to make something from the scrap, or an uninspired crafter discovering new designs and color relationships in a crowd of half formed experiments.
However, years of research and experience in the business and corporate worlds has borne out the idea that neatness does spur productivity. An MRI based study by the Princeton University Neuroscience Institute conducted on subjects in a work environment, concluded that visual disorganization tended to drain a person’s mental resources and reduce their ability to focus. When their study subjects cleared clutter from their work environment, their ability to focus and process information increased as did their productivity. 

So, what does this mean? Most creatives would like to be both innovative and productive, but it would be difficult (although not impossible) to have a studio that is both neat and messy. But maybe the question could be, where do we most need the creativity and where do we most need productivity? Perhaps, the studio table should allow for a bit of chaos and the space where orders are processed, accounting is done, and customer emails are answered should be neat to encourage productivity. But, of course, that can’t be an absolute guideline. We are all different in what we need and what makes us feel at home and ready to work. 

Take a look at these two images. Both artists posted the images, noting their “messy” table in the accompanying text. They are both very creative, productive, and successful artists, yet there is a broad difference in their definition of what is messy. So, this would seem to bear out the idea that there is no particular level of neatness or chaos that best exemplifies the needs of a creative and productive studio space.

Polymer Clay Artist Laura Tabakman's work table.
Polymer clay artist Laura Tabakman's work table.
Polymer clay artist Donna Greenberg's work table.
Polymer clay artist Donna Greenberg's work table.

The real objective, then, is for each creative to find the balance that is right for them. Here are some ideas that might help you manage your space in a way that will best serve you:

  • Identify whether neatness or chaos slows you down, perhaps finding a middle ground by allowing your use of art materials to lean towards the chaotic while prioritizing orderliness for your tools.
  • Give yourself 10 minutes of initial tidying up at the beginning of a studio session. A little organizational time, regardless of a propensity for neatness or chaos, can be a helpful way to ease into the studio mindset, thereby limiting procrastination while likely increasing productivity through your organizational efforts.
  • Measure your level of anxiety when you enter your studio. If you are anxious and the studio is messy, the level of mess may be more than is good for you and could be a source of frustration and a lack of focus. Employ that same 10 minute idea but for cleaning up at the end of a session so you’re less anxious when you next come back to your studio table.
  • Create a moveable mess. If you become anxious seeing any level of disorder when you walk into your studio, try working on a surface you can pick up and stow away at the end of the day. Then when you take it out to get back to work the next time, you are already in the midst of a creative process without having lost time to setting up your workspace or doing much cleaning up to finish.

I’m sure there are many more things that can be done to not just create a studio that supports your creative endeavors but to make it a place that sparks joy as a whole. Just as it is rarely a single stroke or an individual bead but the whole of a piece of artwork that we are drawn to, it is unlikely that there is any single thing about your studio versus the whole of the space and your relationship with it that will determine how well it serves you. So, to define that, step back, take a look at the visual impact of your space, how you organize it, how you move in it, and what it means to you. Change the things that do not work and keep in mind that studios, like you as an artist, are a constant work in progress. Be open to making changes to your studio as you, your circumstances, and your art demands and do not judge its chaos or orderliness, just its purpose and place in your creative journey.

Working from her home studio and office in Thousand Oaks, California, Sage Bray is a writer, mixed-media artist, and the owner of Tenth Muse Arts which offers polymer and mixed media publications including the retrospective Polymer Journeys series, the monthly Virtual Art Box, and the design focused Weekly Polymer Arts blog. These and upcoming projects can be found at www.TenthMuseArts.com

Magazines and books are 30% off during the rest of April. Sale items and the Virtual Art Box are excluded.

Be a Guest Author!

Do you have an interesting polymer clay love story to share? Perhaps a polymer mission you’d like to tell the world about? Get in touch so we can discuss how you can get involved in the Polymer Clay Love project. 

8 thoughts on “Chaos or Cleanliness – A Creative’s Conundrum”

  1. Welp, I’m grateful for the research, and I hope it finds others find their own happy place/what works for them, from this great article. Me? I’ve been in both worlds: The messy/innovative one and the neat/productive one. Back in the recession of 2008, when even my wholesale clients were tanking, what saved me was creating jewelry for a now-defunct mail order catalog. I had to create hundreds of the same item. It saved me financially, but I never want to go there again. To each their own, and I’m simply delighted to find that my very messy creative space is just right for me. (Yeah, I already knew, but now I have scientific proof!) 😀 Thank you, Sage!

  2. Love this 🙂
    I let the chaos reign until I can’t take it anymore – then everything gets put away or trashed.
    Thanks for the insight and tips!

  3. Thanks for making me think about this a little more. I actually do get more ideas when my studio is a mess. It’s part of the momentum that I require to keep making new work. Inertia is my enemy and there is a lot of that to overcome when my studio is too clean.

  4. Like many, I vary as to how neat/ messy I am. I have a big clean up every now and then but am happy to have a degree of creative chaos. One thing that has made a HUGE difference is something I learnt from Sage ages ago and that she mentions here. That is having TOOLS in the same accessible place. I did spend a lot of time on search parties but now I have a place for my tools and try to always return them to that place, it really helps. The creative bits themselves? Well sometimes my balancing acts have to be seen to be believed. I have several tiles and can put “ongoing” on them to be ongone! Great article Sage!

  5. Sherri L Pattee

    I start off all organized with everything I will need, then clean the mess as I go when it starts getting to me or I feel like I don’t have enough room. Usually doing several things at once cuz ya know, while it’s out lol

  6. Whow, what a wonderful article, well thought out. I live in both worlds at the moment, however never too tidy. Currently I am sewing volunteer medical scrubs which requires a reasonable tidy area( have known to accidentally sew an extra floating spare bit of material in a seam)
    However I need to escape at time into my outside studio to do some clay playing, where everything is left, a little like Donna,s studio , until next time.
    So both have to work for me, the creative one gets a big clear out at times but not too often, otherwise not enough time for play. Love the articles, keep them coming, especially at the moment.
    thank you from Australia

  7. What a nice article. 🙂 It made me feel better and gave some pointers to fight back with to friends and family comments about my semi – messy craft space. Most people who don’t have a creative hobby, just see every hobby as kind of a mess. 😀 However in polymer clay world, we do have each other, we are all from different corners of the world but it is amazing how we can all still connect and have each other’s backs online. 🙂

  8. Too clean of a work space for me is akin to the writer’s block authors have when seeing that blank page. I like the creative chaos of bits of this and bits of that laying around. Tools do have a specific home and are always put back where they belong. Every now and then a big clean up is due, which just recently occurred for me so it is funny that this article just appeared.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spread the Love

Use the buttons below to share this article on your social media so your friends can love it, too.

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp

Stay In the Loop

Sign up to get a weekly email summarizing what’s new on Polymer Clay Love.

Polymer Clay Love is a celebration of the creative people, art, and community of polymer clay. It is curated by Ginger Davis Allman and is a community project from:

Scroll to Top

This website uses cookies.